CNIL fines Fnac Darty EUR 7 million: the app kept tracking users who said no
France's CNIL fined two Fnac companies EUR 7 million on 22 October 2026: their app sent user IDs and viewed products to a third party without consent.
On 22 October 2026 the French data protection authority, the CNIL, fined FNAC DARTY PARTICIPATIONS ET SERVICES and FNAC DIRECT a total of EUR 7 million for tracking users of the Fnac mobile app without consent. The CNIL announced the decision (SAN-2026-015) on 29 October 2026. The app kept sending data about what people looked at to a third party, even after they had refused tracking.
What the CNIL found
After a complaint from the association noyb, the CNIL inspected the app in March 2024. It found that:
- the app sent requests through an API to a third-party domain, with an identifier Fnac assigned to the user and their activity, such as products viewed;
- the data was used for personalised recommendations and to train the recommendation algorithm;
- users had not consented, and their refusal was not respected.
The fine is EUR 6 million for FNAC DARTY PARTICIPATIONS ET SERVICES and EUR 1 million for FNAC DIRECT. Within one month of notification the companies must show that their new tool collects consent where needed, or pay EUR 10,000 per day of delay.
Not a cookie, same rule
The tracker was a network request from inside an app, not a cookie, and the rule applied all the same. Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy Directive, which France applies through Article 82 of its Data Protection Act, requires consent to store or read information on a user's device, unless strictly necessary for the communication or a service the user asked for. Personalisation and commercial targeting are not exempt, the CNIL said.
The European Data Protection Board's Guidelines 2/2023 (final version adopted 7 October 2024) say the same across the EU:
- software on a device that calls an API endpoint, or JavaScript that makes the browser send information, "clearly falls within the scope" of Article 5(3);
- device fingerprinting is covered too, including collecting information from HTTP headers such as the user agent.
What to do now
If you run an app or website, make sure "Refuse" stops every tracker: SDKs, API calls and fingerprinting scripts, not only cookies. If you want less of this on the web, use a browser that does it for you: Dazr Browser blocks ads and trackers and hides your device fingerprint, free and in beta. Download Dazr Browser, or read what browser fingerprinting is.
Sources
- CNIL: Cookies et application mobile, sanctions de 7 millions d'euros à l'encontre des sociétés FNAC DARTY PARTICIPATIONS ET SERVICES et FNAC DIRECT (29 October 2026)
- EDPB: Guidelines 2/2023 on Technical Scope of Art. 5(3) of ePrivacy Directive, version 2.0 (adopted 7 October 2024)
- Directive 2002/58/EC (ePrivacy Directive), consolidated version, Article 5(3)
For information only, not legal advice. Last updated 7 November 2026.
Also available in: Nederlands, Italiano, Deutsch, Français, Español, Polski, Português, Română, Čeština, Slovenčina, Dansk, Svenska, Norsk bokmål